GemeWizard
Home|About Us|Store|Color Report Newsletter|Support|News & Events|Contact|Gemstones Colors

Gemstones Colors and Prices



         


   

      Gemewizard archive daily article




The Aurora Collection's Pyramid of Hope display, which was exhibited at the American Museum of Natural History in New York from 1989 to 2005.



  Judge issues ruling, sealing the fate of famed Aurora colored diamond collection


February 15, 2013


A contentious case involving colored diamond expert Alan Bronstein and the family of his late business partner and stepfather, Harry Rodman, over ownership of the famed Aurora colored diamond collection has finally ended, with a New York judge finding in Bronstein's favor.

In 2006, Rodman had transferred his 50 percent share in the 296-fancy colored diamond collection to Bronstein for a nominal $10,000. After Rodman's death in 2008, at age 99, his grandnephew, David Gould, and other members of family petitioned the court to set aside the transfer of ownership, claiming that Bronstein had taken advantage of the older man.

But in her decision rejecting the petition, Bronx Surrogate Judge Lee L. Holzman wrote that "the court finds no basis to set aside the transaction," nor any reason to conclude that Bronstein had committed fraud.

"[Rodman] was clearly capable of understanding the 2006 transaction and ... he viewed Bronstein as a son and a natural object of his bounty," the judge wrote, explaining her decision.

The case generated a large amount of interest in the United States and featured some well -known members of the diamond and gemstone community , who appeared as expert witnesses, including Don Palmieri of GCAL, who appeared on behalf of the Rodman family, and Antoinette Matlins and Gail Brett Levine, who appeared on behalf of Bronstein.

The Aurora Collection, which has a total weight of 267.45 carats and was named for the aurora borealis, was painstakingly put together over almost a quarter of a century. As it grew, Rodman and Bronstein arranged the stones in different patterns. The most famous was the Aurora Pyramid of Hope, which was on public display at the American Museum of Natural History in New York from 1989 to 2005 in the Morgan Hall of Gems. Another was the Aurora Butterfly of Peace, which has been shown at the Smithsonian Institute, and includes 240 natural, fancy colored diamonds in various sizes, shapes, and cuts, weighing 167 carats.

"Thank God I am able to move forward with the dream of making the Butterfly and the Pyramid reside permanently in museums for future generations to enjoy and learn from," Bronstein said to the media following the decision. "It was always Harry's and my wish to perpetuate these natural wonders for the public benefit."

©2007 Menahem Sevdermish, GemEwizard, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Designed by YCS - Yahalom Creative Solutions